> From John Rappaport's StratiaWire > > Tuesday, January 21, 2003 > A DOCTOR REJECTS A SHRINK > JANUARY 21. I received a message from a doctor. A very interesting message. > Here are excerpts: > > "I'm an MD, an internist, board-certified. In no way am I what is called an > alternative practitioner. > > "I never gave much thought to the whole raft of mental disorders which are > being diagnosed these days. Until my ten-year-old son received a diagnosis > of clinical depression. > > "He had been sent, without my knowledge, from his school, to a psychiatrist. > That's how the diagnosis occurred. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "Frankly, at first I thought it was a joke or a mistake. How could anyone > offer a professional opinion that a ten-year old is suffering from clinical > depression? [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "I spoke with the psychiatrist, who was a little taken aback by the fact > that I am a doctor. He was nervous. But he maintained that his diagnosis was > correct. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "I asked him about his prescription for Paxil. That was what my son was > supposed to take. I told the psychiatrist that I had done a little research, > and Paxil is a very powerful drug. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "The psychiatrist didn't have much to say about that. I told him the drug is > heavily addicting, and the withdrawal symptoms can be severe. That alarmed > me. > > "The psychiatrist maintained that it was a good drug for depression. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "I asked him if he was prepared to take full legal responsibility for any > possible effects of the drug on my son. I said I was ready to do > tests.continuing tests to see what effects Paxil was having. I said I was > ready to have other medical people and mental-health people interview my boy > at regular intervals to see what the drug might be doing to do his mental > and emotional state, and I hoped he the school-connected psychiatrist > might suggest a few of these people as well, so we could have an objective > panel of experts. Of course, this was all sheer nonsense. I had no intention > of subjecting my son to interviews or regular blood tests or brain scans > ---and I wasn't about to put him on the drug. But I wanted to see what this > psychiatrist would say. I also told him that it was too bad other children's > parents did not have the resources to undertake such careful medical and > psychological follow-up on their children who were being put on Ritalin and > the SSRIs. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "He the school psychiatrist began to bend. He said he needed to speak with > people at the school---by which I assume he meant lawyers. I said I couldn't > imagine what they would tell him. They weren't medical experts. > > "Finally he said---and I thought this was very interesting---'You know, > Doctor, if you want to make trouble here, and cause everyone a lot of grief, > then I think you should take responsibility for your child. I'll rescind my > prescription.'. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
> > "I told him I WAS taking responsibility for my child. He said he thought > that was matter of opinion. > > "The upshot is, my son is not taking any drugs. He is fine. I spoke with > him, and I found out he was lagging behind in math because he was being > taught in an ineffective way. We got him a tutor who knew what she was > doing, and now he's all caught up. He is no longer 'depressed.'" > > I like them apples. I like them very much. [Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD:
|
Leave a Reply