Nicolas Martin (American Iatrogenic Association) wrote: Dr. Baughman, Thanks very much for your testimonials. You do a superb job of slicing through the chicanery and laying bare the science. As to your question, I can't think of anything more difficult than to challenge a universally held cultural myth
Not only are Americans (and most of the educated world) NOT moving closer to seeing through bogus psychiatry, but they are solidifying their support for the myth. Hence the support for insurance parity, which is being held up only for economic reasons. Insurance parity will dramatically amplify the harm psychiatrists can do since their budgets will be much bigger. Those of us who oppose the myth are few and far between. Every authoritative agency and almost all professionals with influence support the myth. As you know, Thomas Szasz has been opposing the mental health madness for 50 years, and continues to issue forth writings on the subject, but his effect has been slight and his view pessimistic. Breggin has been making useful noises almost that long. I am all for any effort to oppose the psychiatric monster, and I don't want to discourage anyone. But I think it is as likely that lawyers will prevail against ADHD as it would have been for the Spanish Inquisition to have been abolished by a lawsuit. Maybe we can win some skirmishes and save some kids, but the war will take time. What you do is admirable and courageous. It gives me and others ammunition to continue on different fronts, just as Valenstine helps you with his authority and good quotes. So, I hope you will continue the good fight. And it may turn out that I am wrong about the prospects and at least the ADHD tragedy will be swept away. But as Whitaker has shown, the myth has continued apace and claimed many victims. We are all victims of this idiocy. Just getting good ordinary medical care is often more difficult due to psychiatric myths doctors share. I haven't seen you quote Thomas Szasz, so I don't know if you read him, but he has a new book coming out, "Liberation by Oppression: A Comparative Study of Slavery and Psychiatry." (Search Transaction Publishers) A longtime friend of mine, the former chairman of the U. of Kentucky psychology department., is doing a review of it for our website. He is another member of our elite group. He wrote his own critique of the mental health industrial complex, Mind Games (Robert Baker)
Kind regards, Nicolas Martin American Iatrogenic Association |